Wednesday, May 27, 2015

A DUI Lawyer Explains How it is Possible to Fail a Field Sobriety Test

DUI-Lawyer
As a DUI lawyer, I help a lot of people that have been pulled over for the suspicion of drunk driving.  It is important to note that you can be pulled over for driving erratically, and the officer may suspect that alcohol or drugs are involved.  In reality, there are many reasons why a person would not drive perfectly within the lanes even when drugs or alcohol are not involved: turning down the music, handing your son a toy, looking at directions. All of these things and many more, can lead to distracted or careless driving that may have the same general appearance as drunk driving.  Once a traffic stop is initiated and if they officer believes you are driving under the influence, the officer will ask you to submit to a series of Field Sobriety Tests (FSTs). The challenge is that even sober people can (and may even be likely to) fail a field sobriety test. Reasons people fail a field sobriety test: 

If you submit to a field sobriety test, it will be conducted on the side of the road with the potential for traffic rushing by.  The entire experience is both stressful and overwhelming for the majority of people.  Nervousness will often cause the mind and body to react in a way that it normally would not under different circumstances.  According to the Mayo Clinic, symptoms of nervousness or anxiety may include hyperventilation, trembling, sweating, and trouble concentrating or thinking.  All of these symptoms can make it difficult to hear and understand the officer’s commands, much less carry them out without looking physically impaired.

Additionally, as a DUI lawyer, I know that many of these tests require specific acts of balance that are not always attainable by people with a disability or those in poor health.  For example, if someone is severely overweight or recovering from a muscle sprain, standing on one foot may be impossible.  These tests are flawed in that they do not account for medical conditions, anxiety or other factors beyond the officer’s preconceived notion that a driver is impaired.

The type of tests that are demonstrated and why you need a DUI lawyer:
There are several types of FSTs that are conducted throughout the country.  This includes the Finger-to-Nose test, One-Leg Stand test, Walk-and-Turn test and more.  Each test is designed to test the driver’s ability to maintain focus and balance and follow directions. These tests purport to be an accurate indication of whether an individual is under the influence of alcohol or drugs. Again, the difficulty with the FSTs is that they were designed for people that are physically healthy and calm.  The mere act of being pulled over by the police takes away the calm that people would otherwise feel while performing the FSTs.
Exercise your rights.

The FSTs are completely VOLUNTARY and you do not have to submit to any of the Field Sobriety Tests – even the Preliminary Alcohol Screening test is VOLUNTARY. If an officer asks you to submit to the FST, you have every right to say ‘no thank you’. It is likely that you will not complete the FSTs perfectly as demonstrated and any failure to follow the directions of the officer will be highlighted in his report to make it seem as if you are under the influence. You lifted your foot an inch higher than requested? Bad. You opened your eyes slightly? Bad. There was a one-inch gap between the heel-to-toe test? Bad. Do not submit to the FSTs.  
Focus on your defense.

Due to the inability of a FST to ascertain levels of intoxication, many people are arrested and accused of drunk driving without actually being under the influence.  As a DUI lawyer, I can mount a strong defense, illuminate holes or flaws in the process, and work to demonstrate why my client (you) is innocent.  Since a DUI is a criminal misdemeanor charge, it is extremely important to focus on your defense and fight the charges.